Anthony After Shave Balm Review
I started using Anthony After Shave Balm for razor burn and ingrown hairs. Here's how the cooling, non-greasy formula held up in my routine.
This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Quick Verdict
One shave, one thin layer, and the burning and scratching backed off faster than I expected. This after shave goes on smooth, light, not greasy, and it’s already part of my regular personal care regiment.
Buy if you:
- Deal with razor burn and ingrown hairs after shaving
- Have sensitive skin that hates thick, heavy aftershaves
- Want a cooling feel without a strong fragrance
- Prefer a balm that absorbs fast instead of sitting greasy
Skip if you:
- Want that classic sharp aftershave scent, this one’s barely fragranced
- Expect a big tube, it’s only 3 fl oz
- Like a heavier, richer balm that you can feel sitting on skin
Clicking takes you to the seller's website. We may earn a small commission if you purchase, at no extra cost to you.
| Size | 3 fl oz |
|---|---|
| Key ingredients | Aloe vera, vitamins A, C & E, cornmint, eucalyptus |
| Free from | Parabens, phthalates, GMOs, DEA, triclosan |
| Testing | Dermatologist and allergy-tested |
| Made in | USA, cruelty-free |
The Ingrown Hair Problem That Made Me Try This
Ingrown hairs after shaving used to derail my whole week. That’s the whole reason I started using this Anthony After Shave Balm in the first place. I needed something that moisturizes, cools, and calms down the burning and scratching that comes from the razor itself, and I wanted an after shave that wouldn’t fight back against my sensitive skin.
I have to be careful with my skin, thick balms and heavy fragrances have broken me out before. So a formula built around aloe vera with no parabens, no alcohol, and barely any scent was exactly the brief I needed. A week of daily use in, the razor burn that used to linger into the afternoon was gone by the time I finished getting dressed.
What’s In The Tube
It’s a cooling and hydrating lotion with vitamins A, C, and E, plus aloe vera. That aloe was the part I cared about most. Aloe is what gives me that smooth feel on my skin and helps relieve the abuse from shaving. The formula also leans on cornmint and eucalyptus for the cooling side, and it skips the stuff a lot of sensitive-skin folks avoid: no parabens, no phthalates, no DEA. It comes in a 3 fl oz tube, and it’s dermatologist and allergy-tested.
How It Feels Going On
The balm stays even in texture, no weird separation or settling in the tube. When I squeezed it out on camera, it wasn’t overly thick and it wasn’t heavily fragranced. That matters to me. A lot of aftershaves punch you in the nose the second you open them. This one doesn’t.
When I applied it to my face, it went on pretty smooth, really light, not greasy. And it absorbs into my skin well, so I’m not walking around with a shiny film. The relief after a shave is the part I keep coming back to. The burning and scratching from the razor calms down, and that smooth aloe feel takes over instead.
The Fragrance Thing You Should Know
This after shave is barely fragranced, and that cuts both ways. For my sensitive skin it’s a win, less to react to and nothing overpowering. But if you’re someone who loves that classic bracing aftershave smell as part of the ritual, you might feel like something’s missing here. It prioritizes soothing over sensory ritual. I happen to prefer that, but it’s worth knowing before you buy so you’re not surprised when you open the tube.
Get it now
Get the best price on Amazon →This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Who This Is Right For
The clearest signal this is working for me: I stopped skipping the aftershave step on rushed mornings. Before, half my rotation sat unused because something always stung or left a film. This one is thin enough to pat on in ten seconds and step out the door, which is exactly the bar a daily-use product has to clear for sensitive, ingrown-prone skin.
The listing notes it’s formulated for men but loved by women too, and that it works on the neck, legs, underarms, and other sensitive areas, not just the face. I only used it on my face after shaving, so I can speak to that part directly. The light, non-greasy texture makes it easy to reach for every single day rather than saving it for special occasions.
Balm vs. A Splash Aftershave
A balm like this beats a traditional alcohol splash if your skin already takes a beating from the razor. Splash aftershaves sting and can dry you out, which is exactly the opposite of what my ingrown-hair-prone skin needs. This after shave balm goes the other direction, cooling and hydrating with aloe and vitamins instead of that harsh alcohol bite. The trade-off is scent and drama. A splash gives you that sharp cologne-style kick and an instant “clean” signal. This balm is quiet by comparison. For me, calm skin wins over the ritual burn every time, but if the burn is the whole point for you, a splash still has a place.
My Advice Before You Buy
Use less than you think. It’s a light, fast-absorbing balm from a 3 fl oz tube, so a thin layer patted onto damp skin right after shaving does the job. Piling it on won’t make it work harder, it’ll just take longer to sink in. If you’ve got seriously reactive skin, do a small patch test first even though it’s allergy-tested, because everyone’s skin is its own thing. And go in expecting a treatment, not a fragrance experience. Set your expectations there and this one’s easy to like.
Pros
- Goes on smooth, light, and not greasy, absorbs into skin well
- Real relief from razor burn, scratching, and post-shave irritation
- Not overly thick and not heavily fragranced, great for sensitive skin
- Aloe vera plus vitamins A, C, and E give a smooth, calmed feel
- Earned a permanent spot in my personal care routine
Cons
- The light fragrance may disappoint anyone who loves a classic aftershave scent
- 3 fl oz tube isn’t huge if you shave daily
- Lighter texture won’t satisfy fans of a rich, heavy balm you can feel on skin
Frequently Asked Questions
Can women use this after shave too?
Yes. The listing says it’s formulated for men but loved by women, and it’s meant for sensitive areas like legs, underarms, and the bikini line. I only used it on my face, so I can vouch for that use directly, but the non-greasy formula is built for all skin types.
Does it sting or burn on application?
No sting for me. Unlike an alcohol splash, this is a cooling balm, so it calmed the burning from shaving rather than adding to it. That’s a big reason it works for sensitive skin.
How much should I use per shave?
A thin layer is enough. It absorbs quickly and isn’t greasy, so a small amount patted over freshly shaved skin covers the area without any residue. Overapplying just slows down how fast it sinks in.
Is it safe for sensitive or allergy-prone skin?
It’s dermatologist and allergy-tested and free from parabens, phthalates, GMOs, DEA, and triclosan. I have to be careful with my skin and it treated me well, but a quick patch test is still smart if you react to a lot of products.
Will it clog pores or cause breakouts?
The formula is described as non-greasy and won’t clog pores or leave residue. In my experience it absorbed fully and didn’t leave any film behind, so I never felt like it was sitting on top of my skin.
Does it help with ingrown hairs specifically?
It’s marketed to help combat razor bumps and ingrown hairs, and that’s the exact reason I picked it up. It won’t undo an existing ingrown overnight, but the soothing aloe and hydration are aimed at reducing the irritation that leads to them.
How long does a 3 fl oz tube last?
Hard to say precisely, but a 3 fl oz tube used as directed, a thin layer after each shave, should last a daily shaver four to six weeks. The tube is small enough to feel like it’ll disappear fast, but because you’re not piling it on, it moves slower than you’d expect.
Can I use it on days I don’t shave?
Yes, it doubles as a light daily moisturizer thanks to the aloe and vitamins. On non-shave days it works as a simple hydrating step without the greasy feel, though its main strength is that post-shave relief.
Get it now
Anthony After Shave Balm
Get the best price on Amazon →This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
🛍️ Shop everything in this video
Every product mentioned, in one place — these are affiliate links, so I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
🛍️ Anthony After Shave Balm for Men — check price on Amazon →
